Congress Resources: Papers, posters and presentations

< Return to abstract list

Legal Quality Analysis Of Water Services In Buenos Aires, Argentina

Congress: 2015
Author(s): Clara Minaverry (Buenos Aires)

Keyword(s): Sub-theme 15: Water law,
AbstractIntroduction The majority of water resources are salty (97.5%), and the rest belongs to lakes, rivers, reservoirs, underground resources, soil humidity, glaciers and snows. This is one of the main reasons why we should pay attention to what sources we consume every day, as this represents a part of a minority. Another limitation in connection with this is water distribution among the world, its quantity and world population location. In South America this equation is positive, because there is more water resources available than people living in this territory (with the exception of the area of Chile). Only 6% of people living in South America have access to the 26% of the world water resources. The main purpose of this paper is to analyze the efficacy of selected case law and some regulations regarding piped water service quality in the city of Buenos Aires, Argentina. The territorial area of this paper receives water in a direct way, because it is easy to access to the River Plate. This gives these places a physical advantage if we compare it with other territories of the country. Methods/Materials Regarding methodological tool, first, we searched first for regulations and case law in connection with water service quality in Buenos Aires, using the following legal tools: Microjuris, Ecolex and Lexpro. We used the documentary observation method, and the qualitative data were categorized as secondary (regulations and case law). Them, we analyzed three leading cases, which might be useful to set general guidelines for future law projects and public policies in order to achieve a more sustainable service. Results and Discussion At the first place, we analyzed regulations regarding water service quality applied to the Province of Buenos Aires such as: a) Decree 878/2003. b) Law 26.221. We could state that there is a legal overlapping between both regulations, because they apply to the same area and oblige different issues in connection with water quality. The Decree creates a water category which can be used for human consumption, without any quality obligation required to water companies. It also states that this water category can be consumed only for shorts periods of time, but it doesn´t explain for how long. In contrast, the other law fixes different quality requirements to water resources for the same territorial area. Also we studied three leading cases in connection with this analysis: - "Municipalidad de Berazategui against Aguas Argentinas S.A." - "Biondo Esteban against Natural Resources and Human Environment Secretary" - "Conde, Alberto José Luis against Aguas Bonaerenses S.A." Our results show that sanctions are tougher than in other environmental cases which were resolved at a national level. Also, when sanctions are imposed; environmental standards and fines amounts are usually out of date and not relevant to companies finances. In these cases, the defendant is obliged to do something, which is very important in order to have access to a good quality water service. These judicial courts found that public control was not efficient as it should be according to law. Also they set the obligation to design a monitor plan as an additional legal requirement, to complement public control. Conclusions Finally, all along this paper we could achieve our main purpose which was to analyze case law and regulations efficacy, in connection with quality water service in the city of Buenos Aires. We could state that this efficacy is partial, because none of the two regulations provide tools or solutions in connection to improve quality protection for this public service. According to these laws, public controls are lower at the Province of Buenos Aires and also sanctions levels applied for legal unfulfillments or omissions. Also, there is a legal gap because they do not fix dissuasive sanctions for quality water unfulfillments in the city of Buenos Aires, nor an effective quality control system. On the contrary with what happens with case law analysis, sanctions were useful to dissuade legal infulfilment in connection with quality water provision in the city of Buenos Aires, and the existence of a quality control system which were developed by the public sector. But the bad news is that in some case law we found little interdisciplinary willingness in order to work between for the different areas and public offices. ALCAZAR, L.; ABDALA, M.; SHIRLEY, M. The Buenos Aires water concession, The World Bank Development Research Group, Regulation and Competition Policy, p. 21-22, 2000. AGUA Y SANEANIMENTOS ARGENTINOS S. A. – AYSA. Web site. Disponible en: Acceso en: 20 julio 2013. ARGENTINA. Cámara Federal de Apelaciones de La Plata. Municipalidad de Berazategui contra Aguas Argentinas S.A. sobre ordinario. [S.l.]: [s.n.], 2003. ARGENTINA. Cámara Federal de Apelaciones de La Plata. Biondo Esteban contra Secretaría de Recursos Naturales y Ambiente Humano – Poder Ejecutivo Nacional sobre amparo. [S.l.]: [s.n.], 1999. ARGENTINA. Ley 26.221, promulgada en 28 febrero de 2007. Disponible en: Acceso en: 11 marzo 2014. BUENOS AIRES (Provincia). Ley 11820, promulgada en 17 julio 1996. Disponible en: Acceso en: 11 marzo 2014. BUENOS AIRES (Provincia). Cámara de Apelación en lo Contencioso Administrativo de San Martín. Fundación Ecosur Ecológica Cultural y Educ. desde los pueblos del Sur contra Municipalidad de Vicente López y otro sobre amparo. [S.l.]: [s.n], 2008. BUENOS AIRES (Provincia). Suprema Corte de Justicia de la Provincia de Buenos Aires. Conde, Alberto José Luis y otro contra Aguas Bonaerenses S.A. sobre amparo. [S.1.]:[s.n.], 2013CAPALDO, G. Gobernabilidad ambiental y eficacia del Derecho: dos magnitudes del desarrollo sustentable. In: CAPALDO, G. (Ed.). Gobernanza y manejo sustentable del agua. 1. ed. Buenos Aires: Mnemosyne, 2011. p. 39. (Sinergias Ambientales). CENTRO DE ESTUDIOS LEGALES Y SOCIALES (CELS); ASOCIACIÓN CIVIL POR LA IGUALDAD Y LA JUSTICIA (ACIJ); CENTER ON HOUSING AND RIGHTS AND EVICTION (COHRE). El acceso a agua segura en el área metropolitana de Buenos Aires. Una obligación impostergable: programa servicios públicos. Buenos Aires, 2009. p. 14. FERRO, G.; LENTINI, E. Infraestructura y equidad social: experiencias en agua potable, saneamiento y transporte urbano de pasajeros en América Latina. Santiago de Chile: División de Recursos Naturales e Infraestructura, 2012. p. 13. LENTINI, E. Servicios de agua potable y saneamiento: lecciones de experiencias relevantes Santiago de Chile: CEPAL, 2011. p. 39. MINAVERRY, C. Análisis sobre el cumplimiento legal de las inversiones en el servicio público del agua en Buenos Aires, Argentina. Actualidad Jurídica Ambiental, v. 6, p. 1-15, 2013a. MINAVERRY, C. El Derecho como herramienta para la erradicación de escenarios propicios para la corrupción en el servicio de agua. Tesis (Doctoral) - Facultad de Derecho, Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina, 2013b. PRADO, J. Manual de instituciones de derecho público. Buenos Aires: Abeledo Perrot, 1997. p. 260. RED ARGENTINA DE CAPACITACIÓN Y FORTALECIMIENTO EN GESTIÓN INTEGRADA DE LOS RECURSOS HÍDRICOS (Arg Cap-Net). Web site. Acceso: 25 mayo, 2013. ROUSE, M. Institutional governance and regulation of water services. Londres: IWA, 2007. p. 39. SOLANES, M. Descentralización de servicios de agua, eficiencia y acuerdos de protección a la inversión internacional. In: CONFERENCIA INTERNACIONAL SOBRE GESTIÓN DEL AGUA EN PAÍSES FEDERALES Y SEMEJANTES A LOS FEDERALES, 1., 2008, Zaragoza. Memorias… [S.l.: [s.n.], 2008. p. 491-517. TRANSPARENCY INTERNATIONAL. Informe global de la corrupción 2008: corrupción en el sector del agua. Berlín, 2008. p. 22-40.
2011 IWRA - International Water Resources Association - - Admin